The second set of Owaza Jupon contains three techniques that the student has already learned in Junanahon Kata - shihonage, ushiroate, and kotegaeshi. This repetition is typically justified by saying that these throws are done differently in Owaza - more dynamically and in a separating fashion. Well, Dr. Kondo told us a few weeks ago that this is his students' normal operating mode for Junanahon kata, so he felt the repetition in the second half of Owaza Jupon was un-necessary.
So, what would you do about the repetitiveness of this kata?
- Would you maintain the repetitive techniques in Owaza?
- Would you drop these three techniques, reducing the ten-point kata to seven points?
- Or would you substitute new techniques into the kata?
Dr. Kondo's take on this was to substitute three new techniques into the second half of the kata in place of shihonage, ushiroate, and kotegaeshi:
- seoinage - much like the seoinage from nagenokata
- osotogari - much like the nanameuchi osotogari from Kodokan Goshin Jutsu
- ushirodori makikomi - similar to the third technique of junokata, but executed with uke doing a rear bearhug.
This made for some really interesting practice, Things I noticed...
- Unless we study nagenokata a good bit, we probably don't spend enough time throwing seoinage, etc... from fast-moving separated attacks (hamarejudo) like in Owaza Jupon. Even having done nagenokata a good bit, this technique was awkward for me in this particular context.
- Seoinage, if done with a guruma-like emphasis (as would be suggested by throwing this technique into Owaza Jupon) is virtually the same as udeguruma from the first set. This makes for even more repetitiveness in the kata. Speaking of which, I thought it was interesting that the three repeated techniques in the second half of the kata agitated Dr. Kondo but the first three gurumas in the first half (identical except for gripping action) didn't.
- Osotogari was difficult for me to do from this attack with a guruma action. Perhaps osotoguruma would be a better throw in this kata.
- The ushirodori makikomi is really cool - obviously guruma - so it fits well in this context. It also adds another class of attack to the kata (ushirodori) but still illustrates the principles of the exercise (guruma and separation).
What do you think of the repetitiveness of Owaza Jupon? What do you think of this particular solution?
Patrick Parker is a Christian, husband, father, martial arts teacher, Program Director for a Cardiac Rehab, and a Ph.D. Contact: firstname.lastname@example.org or phone 601.248.7282 木蓮